Skip to content

Debt settlement

Settling with creditors, without filing

Sometimes the better answer is a letter, not a petition. If your income is protected or your debts are few, I may be able to negotiate them down for you.

Who it suits

Settlement works best when a creditor can see it would gain little by suing: your income is Social Security or a pension, you own little a judgment could reach, or you have one or two large accounts and a lump sum from family or a tax refund.

How I negotiate

I write to each creditor or its lawyer, explain your situation with documents, and offer a figure you can actually pay. Nothing is paid until the agreement is in writing. Some creditors say no, and I will tell you plainly when an offer is worth taking.

What to weigh first

A forgiven balance can count as income at tax time, and a settled account still marks your credit. Companies that collect monthly deposits for months before they negotiate often leave people deeper in debt. I don’t work that way, and I’ll say so if bankruptcy is the better path.

When a letter beats a petition, and when it doesn’t

  • Settlement may fit

    • One to three large accounts

    • Income a creditor can’t garnish

    • A lump sum you can offer

    • No house or car payments behind

  • Bankruptcy may fit better

    • Many accounts, or lawsuits already filed

    • Wages already being garnished

    • A foreclosure sale on the calendar

    • No money to offer any creditor

Settlement, answered briefly

Will the calls stop?

Once I write to them, most debt collectors have to deal with me rather than you. The original lender may still send statements.

Is a settlement taxed?

A forgiven balance over $600 usually comes with a 1099-C form. If you owed more than you owned at the time, you may not owe tax on it. A tax preparer can confirm.

What does it cost?

A flat fee per account, quoted in writing before I start, never a share of what you save.

Ask whether settlement is worth trying

Tell me who you owe and roughly what you have coming in. I’ll say honestly whether a letter is likely to work.